Learning to Love
By Alicia Anstead, of the News Staff
Published in the July 31, 2000 issue of the Bangor Daily News
When Zoe Weil and Rae Sikora teach seminars on education, they always
ask participants this question: What are the best qualities of human
beings? The answers almost always include: mercy, respect, love, hope,
joy, generosity, honesty, courage and integrity. "These same
qualities come up over and over again," said Weil, an innovative
educator who lives in Surry. "If that is truly what it means to be
humane, then how can we find a way to live by these values and
virtues?" The answer, say Weil and Sikora, is a burgeoning field of
study called humane education. Traditionally, this term has been
associated with the treatment of animals – as in the work of the
Humane Society. But Weil and Sikora are committed to developing a more
comprehensive definition, and their determination is considered by
experts to be trailblazing in the American educational system.
Last week, under the auspices of the International Institute for
Humane Education, a certification program run by the two educators, and
the University of Maine Summer Institute, Weil and Sikora offered EDU
580, a five-day intensive graduate course titled "Humane Education:
Paving the Way for a Compassionate and Sustainable Future." It is,
they believe, the first graduate accredited course in humane education
to be taught in this country. "We’ve been laying the groundwork
for years," said Weil, who earned graduate degrees from Harvard
Divinity School and the University of Pennsylvania before moving to
Maine in the 1990s. "We’re doing this now because we’re finally
ready. Where we are is where environmental studies was 20 years ago and
women’s studies was 40 years ago. As with any field of study, it takes
the grass roots efforts to get it into the academic arena."
The class, which had 16 participants, took place in Surry at the
Center for Compassionate Living, a nonprofit organization founded by the
two women to promote the presence of humane education in all areas of
lifestyle choices. The syllabus included daylong inquiries into animal
issues, human rights, environmental studies and educational practices.
Students’ grades are determined by class participation and a research
paper or project. While Weil and Sikora support the place of the Three R’s
in education, they propose that it’s time for education to take on a
reverence for all forms of life. The elements of humane education, they
say, are a proliferation of information, the encouragement of critical
thinking, the willingness to "fall in love," and insight into
choices available around any given topic.
"By ‘falling in love,’ " said Weil, "I mean
falling in love with the planet, with ourselves and each other. If we
don’t care, what’s going to make us live peaceful, sustainable,
joyful lives?" The approach reemphasizes qualities proposed by the
Maine Learning Results, a state-mandated set of academic standards, but
which sometimes get overlooked or squeezed out in the classroom.
Specifically, these include personal and global stewardship and care for
self, others and the environment. In other words, an outline of humane
education is available at the state level, but isn’t formalized in the
classroom the same way math, English and history are.
"Socially, the world has become global," said Sikora, a
spokeswoman for human and other species rights for more than 20 years.
"What we’ve mostly become is a global mind. What’s happening
here is that the mind is taking along the heart." While there are
individual courses in humane education – such as an animal rights
course taught at Harvard – there is no degree program in the field at
American universities. At the University of Toronto, however, David
Selby heads up a graduate program in humane education. Earlier this year
he taught a workshop there with Sikora and Weil.
"I admire them both immensely and think they are at the very
leading edge of a very holistic conception of human education,"
said Selby, whose textbook "EarthKind" is one of six on the
required reading list for the course in Surry. "We’re talking
about a big contribution to inquiry encouraging children and adults to
reflect upon the values of society, to think about the individual and
about the world view. Education should be about encouraging people to
ask themselves and each other very serious questions about the nature of
being. This is about extending the theory of knowledge – the
epistemology – underpinning education."
More than half of the participants in last week’s course work in
Maine classrooms as teachers, workshop leaders or counselors. Frank
Donaldson, a guidance counselor at Pendleton Street School in Brewer,
took the course because the one he originally enrolled in for summer
credits was canceled. On Friday, he described the week as
"interesting" and "challenging." "A lot of the
material I already knew cognitively, but seeing it upfront had shock
value," said Donaldson, who works with children in kindergarten
through second grade. "The course brought it more forward in my
consciousness." Donaldson wasn’t sold on the practical
application for classrooms, where he says ideas of all kinds should have
balanced representation. But he said he was impressed by the commitment
of the program organizers. Still, that word "balance" can
easily raise the eyebrow of any activist.
"Humane education is a new field of study and we don’t know
for sure what the specific practical results will be," said
Josephine Donovan, a UM professor of English and author of the book
"Animals and Women: Feminist Theoretical Explorations."
"Specifically in elementary and secondary schools, there is a need
to develop a more empathetic and nonviolent attitude toward animals,
other human beings and the natural world, and create a more
compassionate world. There’s a growing interest in this among
students, especially at the university level. So I think it’s the way
of the future. In a way, what the Center for Compassionate Living is
trying to do is, in fact, provide balance with the overwhelming
socialization of the other side." Others in the fight to invigorate
humane action are also eager to see what the results of a formalized
educational standard will be.
"First, I think it’s amazing that anyone would have the
courage and audacity to invent a Center for Compassionate Living in the
first place, to say nothing of creating a curriculum to actually take
into schools," said Jon Wilson, editor and founder of HOPE magazine
in Brooklin. "In this day and age, when so many of us seem so
focused on money and material things, this is a highly unusual kind of
vision and commitment. Yet it is precisely what is required in our
culture – that people of courage stand up for what they believe is
possible, no matter how unusual, no matter how seemingly far from the
mainstream. My admiration for the work that Rae and Zoe are doing – so
full of intention and rigor – is just unending. I think the ground
they are breaking is tremendously important."
Sydney Thomas, a professor of counselor education at UM and the
administrative force for getting the course accredited, said she would
like to see the course become a requirement for master’s and doctoral
students in her department. Her own work in animal-assisted therapies
has shown her the value of teaching children compassion at an early age.
"Now is the time for this," said Thomas, who sat in on the
course. "We’re frightened about school violence. There’s a lack
of respect on the part of students, but also on the part of teachers. We’re
busy, busy, busy. People may see humane education as soft, tree-hugger,
1960s hippie stuff. But what impressed me is that Rae and Zoe are not at
all like that. This is not the tree-hugger mentality. They are teaching
people to be effective communicators and are saying: ‘Why not tell the
truth?’ What could be more important than that?"
As an introductory activity on the first day of class, Sikora and
Weil did an awareness raising activity called "Wonder Walk."
Each participant paired with a partner for a walk around the Center’s
pastoral grounds, including a meadow of wildflowers with a trail leading
to a pebble beach and a view of the mountains of Mount Desert Island.
While one person closed his or her eyes, the other led a walk through
nature – stopping to smell a flower, listen to a buzzing bee, taste an
herb from an organic garden or watch a bug crawl through the grass.
Then, after 15 minutes, the partners switched places, and began again.
The purpose of the Wonder Walk is, essentially, to take time to smell
the roses. Or, put another way, to tenderly reconnect with the natural
world and with another human being through one’s own senses. At the
end, Thomas posed a telling question: "What would happen if you did
something like that every day? What would it do for your soul?"
Weil summed up both the activity and the course by posing yet another
question. "How many of you found a little bit of falling in love
during this?" asked Weil, whose family lives at the Center.
"When we really find out what’s at stake with this planet, when
we really fall in love with this planet, we’ll take care of it, of
other species and of ourselves ."